Why We Cling to Grief “Rules”
Finding order in chaos is an instinct we may feel when grieving. We want to make sense of what we’re thinking and feeling. But we might fall into the Grief Literacy trap, where trying to figure out rules and definitions actually distances us from the messy experience of grief.
Whether you’re experiencing grief or trying to support someone who is, trying to follow grief rules is a natural response. True healing doesn’t come from mastering the rules of grief, but from the courage to be with it.
The Myth of the Five Stages of Grief
People often confuse Elisabeth Kübler-Ross’ book, The Five Stages of Death, as a way to think about the experience of grief. But Kübler-Ross was writing for patients coming to terms with dying, not for people grieving.
There is no clinical research to support the idea that there are stages of grief.
Grief is less like climbing stairs and more like a pinball machine. You might wake up feeling okay, but start to feel anger at lunch because you saw your loved one’s favorite food, and then end the day in denial. This might feel like regression, but it isn’t. This is how grief moves.
Unlearning the Pressure to “Fix”
As a supporter, you might not know what to say to someone grieving. We often have an urge to fix pain, especially in loved ones, as it can trigger our biological distress. This is called empathic distress in neuroscience. We see someone cry, which triggers our neurons to fire, making us feel a shadow of their pain. We then feel the urge to stop the tears to help soothe ourselves and others.
Instead of trying to fix the pain or offer solutions, your job is to witness the pain with those in need so they aren’t alone in it. It’s okay to offer a tissue, but avoid giving silver linings as they can invalidate the experience of grief. These are thoughts like “everything happens for a reason.”
Instead, think about staying present rather than trying to make the other person smile. Some strategies on how to be present include:
- Give it 10 seconds: When you feel the urge to speak, especially if you notice a silver lining thought coming, count to 10. This gives the griever space to fill the silence or simply sit and be with their grief with you as their witness.
- Label your anxiety: Notice when you feel uncomfortable or when your heart rate spikes when you see someone in distress. Remind yourself that it is okay to feel anxious if someone you care about is in pain. Reassure yourself that you are safe and they are safe to feel what they’re feeling. This helps you separate your distress from theirs, so you don’t rush in to fix their emotions.
- Ask them: Ask the person what they need in that moment. They may just need someone to vent to, or an activity to take their mind off things.
Moving From Literacy to “Grief Humility”
To move from grief literacy to grief humility, you can embrace the relief of admitting that you don’t know exactly how someone else feels when grieving, but that’s okay.
Grief literacy or competence is about trying to have all the answers. Grief humility is being willing to sit in the silence. This approach removes the pressure to be perfect and allows for genuine, awkward human connection.
Here are some examples of what this might sound like:
- Grief literacy: “At least they aren’t suffering anymore. Everything happens for a reason. You are so strong.”
- Grief humility: “It makes sense that you are devastated. I don’t have the right words, but I am here. I hate that you are going through this.”
The Art of Holding Space for Grief
One way to embrace grief and humility is to hold space. When you hold space for somebody experiencing grief, you act as a container for big emotions without shrinking them or spilling them.
This isn’t just a skill for therapists — it is a necessary life skill for our communities. For example, 1 in 11 children in the U.S. will experience the death of a parent or sibling by age 18. Grief is statistically inevitable and we likely need to hold space for a loved one, colleague or friend at some points in our lives.
You can hold space in a few ways, such as:
- Listen without planning your responses.
- Give validating responses. Acknowledge that it makes sense why someone is feeling angry or sad, for example.
- Be prepared to sit in silence rather than distract or change the subject.
Relearning How to Trust Your Own Grief Process
Shifting the way you perceive grief and its process takes time. One of the first realizations to make is that grief takes as long as it takes. There isn’t a set schedule to follow. Trust your own grief process and know that feeling angry or numb today doesn’t mean you’re broken— it means you’re human.
You can also give yourself permission to set boundaries. You can decline social events, refuse to talk about the deceased or even step away from conversations that feel too prescriptive. You don’t have to comfort the people who are supposed to be comforting you.
When you’re learning how to trust your grief process, you may find it helpful to reach out for professional help. There are different methods you can try:
- Person-centred therapy: In person-centred therapy, you can access a space with no rules to follow where you can process your experiences without judgment. The therapist is there to witness your grief and help you explore what it looks like to simply be with your loss.
- Cognitive behavior therapy (CBT): CBT gives you the skills to reframe unhelpful thoughts and develop ways to cope with grief. This can help you distinguish between hindsight and foresight. You can learn to forgive yourself for not predicting the future and accept how you feel in the present.
- Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT): With DBT, you can learn mindfulness and emotional regulation techniques to deal with feelings of loss. For example, it can help you hold two opposing truths, like “I am distraught from this loss,” and “I can still get out of bed today.”
Process Your Grief With Support From Merrimack Valley Psychological Associates
Unlearning grief rules can be daunting but also liberating. Learning to hold space for grief for someone in need is a way to truly connect with and support that person. Reaching out for support from a therapist gives you the space to be with your grief and begin the healing process.
Merrimack Valley Psychological Associates in Andover, Massachusetts, offers a flexible approach to grief counseling that meets you where you are in your grief process. We offer a range of therapy options to suit your needs. Reach out to our team for a non-judgmental space to explore your unique path through loss.